The software development process encompasses multiple stages, from identifying needs and requirements to ensuring smooth operation.

To navigate this complex journey, developers rely on frameworks that serve as guidelines to streamline the process.

In this blog, we'll explore a prominent framework, V-Model in software
development, in terms of:

  • The V-Model process.
  • The advantages and disadvantages of V- development.
  • The core principles guiding the V-Model.

Let's start our journey with some basis:

Table of contents [ Hide ]
What is V-Model in software development?
Advantages and Disadvantages of V-Model
2 Phases of V-Model in Software Development
Verification
Validation
4 Principles of V-Model
Key Takeaways

What is V-Model in software development?

The V-Model is an updated iteration of the Waterfall Model in software development. Both approaches follow a sequential structure, where each phase must conclude before the next begins.

Key Differences:

  • Testing Integration: While the Waterfall Model treats testing as a single, post-development phase, the V-Model incorporates testing with every step in the development process.

  • Bug Detection: The V-Model enables earlier and more frequent bug detection compared to the Waterfall Model.

Before discussing further, we will look into a crucial insight of bugs fixing cost.

Recent research by Shafiq et al. (2023) highlights that the later a bug is detected in the development cycle, the more expensive it becomes to fix.

V-Model - Bugs detection cost

It's important to note that this model has its own Advantages and Disadvantages, which we'll explore further in the following sections.

Advantages and Disadvantages of V-Model

Advantages

  • Testers can create detailed testing plans for each development stage, allowing for thorough software examination.

  • Developers can easily trace issues back to specific development stages, facilitating quicker adjustments.

  • This model uses a straightforward and understandable framework, making it easier to assign tasks and monitor progress.

Disadvantages

  • Bugs appeared in latter stages of testing requires higher level of effort to adjust as they may related to earlier stages of the development process.

2 Phases of V-Model in Software Development

The V-Model in software development is characterized by its distinctive V-shaped structure, comprising two main phases: Verification and Validation.

Each step in the Validation phase corresponds to a step in the Verification phase.

This alignment ensures that testing activities directly relate to the planning and design decisions made earlier in the development process.

2 Phases of V-Model in Software Development

VerificationValidation

The Verification phase answers the question: "Are we building the right software?"

The Validation phase answers the question: "Are we building the software right?"

Key Characteristics

  • Employs static testing methods.

  • Focuses on document review and analysis.

Key characteristics

  • Utilizes dynamic testing methods.

  • Emphasizes practical testing.

Steps typically include:

  • Requirements analysis.

  • System design.

  • Architecture design.

  • Module design.

Steps typically include:

  • Unit testing.

  • Integration testing.

  • System testing.

  • Acceptance testing.

Now, let’s go into detail about 2 phases in the V-Model:

v-model framework

Verification

The Verification phase aims to thoroughly identify customer requirements and expectations, and evaluate the team's strategy for meeting these needs.

This phase serves as the foundation for subsequent steps, with five crucial stages:

Phase 1: Business Requirement Analysis

  • Project managers engage with clients to understand their requirements and expectations.

  • The overall project scope is determined.

  • Business requirements Analysis help evaluate the team's strategy for meeting customer needs.

  • This stage provides input for developing User Acceptance Tests (UATs).

Phase 2: System Design

  • The team collaborates to create an overview of the system design.

  • Tasks and their descriptions are listed, including their relationships to each other and external factors.

  • Testers create a detailed plan with input and output criteria for system tests.

Phase 3: Architectural Design

  • Team constructs the project's operational structure, including outlining elements and their relationships.

  • Testers write integration test plans to validate effective interaction between various project systems.

Phase 4: Module Design

The project is divided into smaller, simpler modules with detailed internal designs for each module.

The module design document includes:

  • Database tables.

  • Interface specifics.

  • Dependent problems.

  • Error message listings.

  • Input and output criteria.

Phase 5: Implementation

Developers select the most suitable tech stack and programming languages based on system and architectural design specifications.

  • Code is tested and optimized for performance.

  • Completed modules are added to a central repository where all source code files are stored.

Validation

The Validation phase builds upon the output from the Verification phase. This phase ensures the software functions correctly and meets customer expectations.

It comprises four key testing stages:

Phase 1: Unit Testing

  • Testers execute Unit Test Plans created during module design.

  • This step ensures each component operates correctly in isolation.

  • This testing focuses on individual modules, the smallest components of the program, which helps identify and resolve issues quickly by pinpointing root causes.

Phase 2: Integration Testing

  • Testers conduct integration tests to assess interactions between various program components.

  • This step verifies that different parts of the software work together as required.

Phase 3: System Testing

At this stage, testers team evaluates the complete system.

  • The test provides a comprehensive understanding of:

  • Overall program functionality.

  • Interdependence between components.

  • System interactions.

Phase 4: Acceptance Testing

  • User Acceptance Tests (UATs) are employed to evaluate if the application meets user requirements.

  • This test is often conducted in genuine user environments for accurate data, which identifies areas needing improvement before project completion.

4 Principles of V-Model

The V-Model in Software Development adheres to four key principles that guide its implementation:

v-model - 4 principles

  • Hierarchical order: While Verification phase progresses from large to smaller components, the Validation phase evaluates from smaller modules to the entire system. This structure ensures comprehensive coverage at all levels of development.

  • Scalability: The V-Model adapts to IT projects of varying from size, complexity, to duration.

  • Cross-referencing: Each step in the verification phase corresponds to a step in the validation phase. This association simplifies bug detection and root cause analysis.

  • Clear Documentation: V-Model requires comprehensive guidelines for input and output criteria at each step. This not only facilitates effective communication with customers and promotes transparency within the team.

Key Takeaways

The V-Model, while not a universal solution for all software development projects, offers significant advantages when applied appropriately.

Its structure and principles provide a robust framework for many development scenarios.

Key takeaways from our exploration of the V-Model include:

  • Its evolution from the Waterfall Model, enhancing testing integration throughout the development process.

  • The dual phases of Verification and Validation, each with distinct yet interconnected steps.

  • Four guiding principles: Hierarchical Order, Scalability, Cross-referencing, and Clear Documentation.

Development teams should carefully consider the V-Model's workflows, advantages, and disadvantages when deciding whether to adopt this approach.

For complex projects, combining the V-Model with other methodologies may yield optimal results.

Read more about Software Development Models here.